Jump to content
Peace Through Law / Chapter 5 Negotiating Equality: Minority Protection in the Versailles Settlement
Peace Through Law / Chapter 5 Negotiating Equality: Minority Protection in the Versailles Settlement
Contents
Chapter
Expand
|
Collapse
Authors
Page
1–10
Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis
1–10
Details
11–28
Introduction: Versailles and the Broadening of ‘Peace Through Law’
Michel Erpelding
Michel Erpelding
11–28
Details
1. Peace Through Law?
Details
2. The Establishment of a New International Order of Peace
Details
3. The Emergence of International Economic Law
Details
4. The Institutionalization of International Adjudication
Details
5. Beyond ‘Peace Through Law’: The Use of Law and Its Records as Vehicles of Resistance and Change
Details
29–64
Part 1: Peace Through Law?
29–64
Chapter 1 Drama Through Law: The Versailles Treaty and the Casting of the Modern International Stage
Nathaniel Berman
Nathaniel Berman
Details
1. Prologue: Noël, 1913
Details
2. A Dramatic Gesture
Details
3. The Dramatis Personae and the Actors: Dynamics and Indeterminacy
Details
4. The Agon of the Personae
Details
5. Dramatic Anomalies
Details
6. Destructive Parody
Details
7. No Exit?
Details
8. The ‘Art of Justice’ and the ‘Smoking Crater’
Details
9. Conclusion … or Not?
Details
65–156
Part 2: The Establishment of a New International Order of Peace
65–156
65–84
Chapter 2 The League of Nations as a Universal Organization
Thomas D Grant
Thomas D Grant
65–84
Details
1. Introduction
Details
2. Sovereign Equality Emerging—But not Entrenched
Details
3. Admission, Voting, and Sovereign Equality in the League
Details
4. Other Aspects of Participation
Details
5. Conclusion
Details
85–98
Chapter 3 Preventing a Repetition of the Great War: Responding to International Terrorism in the 1930s
Michael D Callahan
Michael D Callahan
85–98
Details
99–122
Chapter 4 The Legacy of the Mandates System of the League of Nations
Mamadou Hébié, Paula Baldini Miranda da Cruz
Mamadou Hébié, Paula Baldini Miranda da Cruz
99–122
Details
1. Introduction
Details
2. The Innovative Character of the Mandates System of the League of Nations
Details
2.1. The Principle of Non-Annexation of Territories Upon Military Victory
Details
2.2. The Internationalization of the Treatment of Certain Colonial Populations
Details
2.3. The Institutionalization of a Droit de Regard with Respect to the Treatment of Certain Colonial Populations
Details
3. The Mandates System of the League of Nations as a Continuation of Colonialism
Details
3.1. The Mandates System as a Formalization of the Interests of Colonial Powers
Details
3.2. The Reliance of the Mandates System on the Right of Civilization
Details
3.3. The Mandates System as an Entrenchment of Colonial Domination
Details
4. Conclusion
Details
123–156
Chapter 5 Negotiating Equality: Minority Protection in the Versailles Settlement
León Castellanos-Jankiewicz
León Castellanos-Jankiewicz
123–156
Details
1. Introduction
Details
2. National Minorities and the Great War
Details
2.1. Wartime Mistreatment of Minorities
Details
2.2. The Allies’ War Aims and National Minorities
Details
2.3. Woodrow Wilson’s Fourteen Points and Self-Determination
Details
3. Equality and the Covenant: Failure or Qualified Success?
Details
3.1. Wilson’s Equal Treatment Clauses
Details
3.2. Japan’s Racial Equality Clause
Details
3.3. Equality in the Polish Treaty: Defining Moments
Details
4. Concluding remarks
Details
157–214
Part 3: The Emergence of International Economic Law
157–214
157–182
Chapter 6 Managing the ‘Workers Threat’: Preventing Revolution Through the International Labour Organization
Guy Fiti Sinclair
Guy Fiti Sinclair
157–182
Details
1. Introduction
Details
2. From Revolution to Reform
Details
3. Legal Proceduralism versus Revolution
Details
4. Law and Morality: Towards Responsive Law
Details
5. Law and/as Expertise
Details
6. Conclusion
Details
183–192
Chapter 7 The Role of Private International Law: UNIDROIT and the Geneva Conventions on Arbitration
Herbert Kronke
Herbert Kronke
183–192
Details
1. Introduction: Terminology and the Historical Context
Details
2. UNIDROIT
Details
2.1. The Institutional Framework
Details
2.2. The Work Programme, and the Individuals
Details
2.3. 1937: Not the End, but a Transition into the Unknown
Details
3. The Geneva Arbitration Conventions
Details
3.1. Political Background
Details
3.2. The 1923 Protocol on Arbitration Clauses
Details
3.3. The 1927 Convention on the Execution of Foreign Arbitral Awards
Details
3.4 Overall Assessment
Details
4. Conclusion
Details
193–204
Chapter 8 Article 231 of the Versailles Treaty and Reparations: The Reparation Commission as a Place for Dispute Settlement?
Jean-Louis Halpérin
Jean-Louis Halpérin
193–204
Details
1. Three Steps Towards Drafting Article 231 of the Versailles Treaty and One Step Towards the Reparation Commission
Details
1.1 An American Idea
Details
1.2 A British Enlargement
Details
1.3 An Inter-Allied Compromise
Details
1.4 The Reparation Commission as a New Deal
Details
2. The Failure to Affirm the Reparation Commission as an Independent Tribunal
Details
2.1 The Ambiguous Status of the Reparation Commission
Details
2.2 The Obstacles for Transforming the Reparation Commission into an Independent Tribunal
Details
2.3 The Turning Point of 1922
Details
205–214
Chapter 9 The Conversion of Reparations into Sovereign Debts (1920–1953)
Pierre d’Argent
Pierre d’Argent
205–214
Details
1. Morality, Law, and the Economists
Details
2. The Magnitude of the German Reparation Debt
Details
3. The Ruhr Crisis and the Dawes Plan
Details
4. The Young Plan and Its Aftermath
Details
5. The Versailles Reparations in Perspective
Details
215–322
Part 4: The Institutionalization of International Adjudication
215–322
215–238
Chapter 10 Peace Through International Adjudication: The Permanent Court of International Justice and the Post-War Order
Christian J Tams
Christian J Tams
215–238
Details
1. Introduction
Details
2. A New, but Modest, Beginning: Binding Dispute Resolution in the Post-war Order
Details
2.1. A World Court at Last
Details
2.2. A World Court with a Modest Brief
Details
3. A Pragmatic Pioneer: the PCIJ in Operation
Details
3.1. Sticking to the Brief: the Court as a Dispute Settler
Details
3.2. ‘Gradually Moulding International Law’: the Court as an Agent of Legal Development
Details
4. Concluding Thoughts
Details
239–276
Chapter 11 International Adjudication of Private Rights: The Mixed Arbitral Tribunals in the Peace Treaties of 1919–1922
Marta Requejo Isidro, Burkhard Hess
Marta Requejo Isidro, Burkhard Hess
239–276
Details
1. Origins and Legal Framework
Details
1.1. Private Rights in the Peace Treaties
Details
1.1.1. War Measures Against the Property of ‘Ennemis Nationaux’
Details
1.1.2. Private Rights and Interests in the Peace Treaties
Details
1.2. The Establishment of the Mixed Arbitral Tribunals
Details
1.2.1. The Pertinent Provisions in the Peace Treaties
Details
1.2.2. The Competences of the MATs
Details
1.2.3. The German–US Peace Treaty of 1922
Details
2. The Organization of the Mixed Arbitral Tribunals
Details
2.1. Historical and Statistical Background
Details
2.1.1. A New Model for the Settlement of International Disputes
Details
2.1.2. Statistical Data
Details
2.2. The Composition of the Tribunals
Details
2.2.1. The Judges and the Secretariats
Details
2.2.2. The State Agents
Details
2.2.3. The Position of the Individual Claimants
Details
2.3. The Procedures Applied
Details
2.4. The Interfaces with Domestic Procedures
Details
2.4.1. The Basic Regime
Details
2.4.2. Concurrent Pending Jurisdiction in National Courts
Details
2.4.3. Finality and Enforceability
Details
3. The Legal Nature of the Mixed Arbitral Tribunals
Details
3.1. The Contemporary Debate
Details
3.1.1. National or International Tribunals
Details
3.1.2. General/Special Jurisdiction
Details
3.2. Modern Parallels
Details
4. Private International Law in the Case Law of the Mixed Arbitral Tribunals
Details
4.1. Nationality and Standing
Details
4.2. The Application of Conflict of Law Rules by the MATs
Details
4.2.1. The Debate Among Scholars
Details
4.2.2. The Case Law of the MATs
Details
5. Assessment
Details
5.1. A Preferred Way of Dispute Settlement in the 1920s
Details
5.2. A Practical Drawback: The Fragmentation of the Case Law
Details
5.3. Are There Lessons to be Learned?
Details
277–322
Chapter 12 Local International Adjudication: The Groundbreaking ‘Experiment’ of the Arbitral Tribunal for Upper Silesia
Michel Erpelding
Michel Erpelding
277–322
Details
1. Introduction: Mitigating the Side-Effects of Self-Determination
Details
2. Procedural Innovations: The Tribunal’s Toolbox
Details
2.1. Direct Individual Claims for Compensation
Details
2.2. Indirect Individual Claims
Details
2.3. Evocation Procedure
Details
2.4. Power to Create General Binding Precedent
Details
3. Implementing Local International Adjudication: The Tribunal at Work
Details
3.1. Setting Up the Tribunal
Details
3.2. Engaging with the Local Population
Details
3.3. Dealing with the States Parties
Details
4. Defending the Tribunal’s Legacy
Details
5. Conclusion: From Upper Silesia to Luxembourg?
Details
323–354
Part 5: Beyond ‘Peace Through Law’: The Use of Law and Its Records as Vehicles of Resistance and Change
323–354
323–336
Chapter 13 Resistance Through Law: Belgian Judges and the Relations Between Occupied State and Occupying Power
Didier Boden
Didier Boden
323–336
Details
1. Overall Approach
Details
1.1. Article 43 of the Annex to the 1907 Hague Convention
Details
1.2. The Belgian Interpretation
Details
1.2.1. The Majority’s Interpretation
Details
1.2.2. The Interpretation of de Ryckère and Benoidt.
Details
1.2.3. ‘Whereas the Independence of the Belgian Courts Has Been Infringed...’
Details
2. Variety of Concrete Aspects
Details
2.1. Categories of Possible Effects
Details
2.2. Three Illustrations
Details
2.2.1. Criminal Law
Details
2.2.2. Contract Law
Details
2.2.3. International Private Law (Outside Occupied Belgium)
Details
3. Epilogue
Details
337–354
Chapter 14 The Work of Peace: World War One, Justice and Translation Through Art
Jennifer Balint, Neal Haslem, Kirsten Haydon
Jennifer Balint, Neal Haslem, Kirsten Haydon
337–354
Details
1. Introduction
Details
2. Translating Foundational Moments
Details
3. Ottoman Courts-Martial
Details
4. Art as a Means of Making Visible
Details
5. Flowers of War
Details
6. Peace Through Law: Conclusion
Details
Durchsuchen Sie das Werk
Geben Sie ein Keyword in die Suchleiste ein
CC-BY
Access
Peace Through Law , page 123 - 156
Chapter 5 Negotiating Equality: Minority Protection in the Versailles Settlement
Autoren
León Castellanos-Jankiewicz
DOI
doi.org/10.5771/9783845299167-123
ISBN print: 978-3-8487-5754-1
ISBN online: 978-3-8452-9916-7
Chapter Preview
Chapter Preview
Share
Current chapter
Complete document
Download citation
RIS
BibTeX
Copy DOI link
doi.org/10.5771/9783845299167-123
Share by email
Video schließen
Share by email Nomos eLibrary
Recipient*
Sender*
Message*
Your name
Send message
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy
and
Terms of Service
apply.
