Jump to content
Leniency Policies in the Prosecution of Economic Crimes and Corruption / Conclusion
Leniency Policies in the Prosecution of Economic Crimes and Corruption / Conclusion
Contents
Chapter
Expand
|
Collapse
Page
1–16
Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis
1–16
Details
17–28
Introduction
17–28
Details
29–85
Chapter I – The development of leniency policies in Brazilian criminal justice and the contractualist approach to collaboration agreements
29–85
Details
1. Introduction
Details
2. The Brazilian procedural tradition and the recent development of leniency policies
Details
a. Competition law
Details
b. Criminal law
Details
3. The legal structure of Brazilian leniency policies
Details
a. The negotiation dynamic: consensual arrangements, written agreements and informal communication
Details
b. Terms of trade
Details
i. Benefits: immunities and reduction of penalties
Details
ii. Duties: cooperation with the investigations
Details
c. Signing and fulfillment of the agreement
Details
4. The inventive practice of collaboration agreements: development and judicial support
Details
a. Law in action, consensual innovations and the expansion of the room for negotiations
Details
i. Granting of benefits not provided for by law
Details
ii. Exact definition of imprisonment penalties
Details
iii. Package deals and “unified punishment”
Details
iv. The serving of imprisonment penalties in advance
Details
b. Contractual freedom, tailor-made arrangements and unique consensual solutions
Details
c. A new model of criminal procedure? Collaboration agreements and consensual criminal justice
Details
i. The binding effect of collaboration agreements: pacta sunt servanda in criminal procedure
Details
ii. The principle of “res inter alios acta” and the prohibition of legal challenges by third parties
Details
5. Conclusion: a contractualist approach to collaboration agreements
Details
86–112
Chapter II – Collaboration agreements and macro-delinquency in Brazilian recent experience: notable results in the prosecution of corruption networks
86–112
Details
1. Introduction
Details
2. Operation Car Wash
Details
3. Corruption networks
Details
a. Collective goods, diffuse losses
Details
b. Legitimate and sophisticated organizations
Details
c. Major impacts on social life
Details
4. Storming the castle: macro-delinquency, consensual justice and public support for leniency policies
Details
5. Conclusion: the will and the way for the practice of collaboration agreements
Details
113–149
Chapter III – Leniency policies: rationale, expectations and risks
113–149
Details
1. Introduction
Details
2. The rationale and expectations of leniency policies: optimal deterrence through increased detection and prevention
Details
a. Detection of crimes and gathering of evidence
Details
b. Prevention of illegal activities
Details
3. Principal-agent relationships, information asymmetry and the risks of leniency policies
Details
a. Misrepresentation of facts: under- and over-cooperation
Details
b. The dark side of leniency: amnesty effect, recidivism and the need for limits
Details
c. Distortion of incentives for enforcement authorities: leniency over-reliance, statistical boost and the overheated market for cooperation
Details
d. Gaming the leniency system: repeated games, sophisticated agents and reverse exploitation
Details
4. Conclusion: leniency revolution and leniency religion
Details
150–213
Chapter IV – Consensual exchanges in German criminal procedure: the practice of negotiated judgments and the crown-witness regulation
150–213
Details
1. Introduction
Details
2. Negotiated judgments: practice and regulation
Details
a. Search for truth, compulsory prosecution and consent in the German tradition
Details
b. Development of the practice of negotiated judgments
Details
c. Judicial acknowledgement
Details
d. The legislative regulation of negotiated judgments
Details
e. The 2013 ruling of the German Constitutional Court
Details
3. The general crown-witness regulation
Details
a. Development
Details
b. Structure
Details
c. Scope of application: investigative emergencies
Details
d. Investigative achievements, essential contributions and positive balances
Details
e. Inside and outside cooperators: the issue of the connection requirement
Details
4. Points of analysis
Details
a The prosecution of economic crimes: between consent and search for truth
Details
i. Negotiated judgments and crown-witness regulation: parallels and differences
Details
ii. Consent and search for truth: different answers to similar questions? Disenchantment and re-enchantment with truth-finding in criminal procedure
Details
b. Expansion of the negotiation forum, externalities and abstinence from the search for truth
Details
i. The tension over the boundaries of the room for negotiation and the troublesome taming of negotiated judgments
Details
ii. Negative externalities and abstinence from the search for truth
Details
iii. The 2013 ruling of the German Federal Constitutional Court and the case-law of the U.S. Supreme Court: unnoticed virtues?
Details
5. Conclusion
Details
214–277
Chapter V – Truth and consent in collaboration agreements: a rebuff to the contractualist approach
214–277
Details
1. Introduction
Details
2. The practice of collaboration agreements: incompatibility with Brazilian criminal justice and counterproductive effects
Details
a. Collaboration agreements as exceptional tools for investigative emergencies
Details
b. Due process, search for truth and the chain of events in criminal procedure
Details
c. Separation of functions in criminal procedure: the return of the inquisitorial process?
Details
d. Investigative achievements, information asymmetry and the risks of forward purchases in the practice of collaboration agreements
Details
3. Collaboration agreements as public-private partnerships within criminal justice: the privatization of truth-finding and its effect on third parties
Details
a. Triangular relationships, not bilateral transactions
Details
b. Collaboration agreements as mechanism of consensual justice? Disenchantment and reenchantment with truth-searching in criminal procedure
Details
c. Collaboration agreements as public-private partnerships and the privatization of official investigations
Details
d. Is there a Brazilian system of plea bargaining? Legal transplants, legal translations and legal counterfeits
Details
e. The contractual redesign of Brazilian criminal law
Details
4. The judicial control of collaboration agreements
Details
a. Pacta sunt servanda or nemo dat quod non habet? The issue of the binding effect
Details
b. Negative externalities, private gains and social costs: the distorted use of collaboration agreements as hedging mechanisms
Details
c. The overheated cooperation market and the problem of monopoly of selection: a case for broad and in-depth judicial control of collaboration agreements
Details
5. Conclusion: the contractualist approach from a comparative perspective
Details
278–318
Chapter VI – Legal consequences and practical implications
278–318
Details
1. Introduction
Details
2. Consequences
Details
a. The right of third parties to question collaboration agreements in court: protection of individual rights and of the public interest
Details
b. The array of leniency benefits: a case for numerus clausus
Details
c. The guarantee of equal treatment and the bazaar of punishment
Details
d. Disclosure and confidentiality: cooperators as the monopolists of truth
Details
e. Advanced enforcement of penalties and the paradox of investigating what has already been determined
Details
f. Preparatory acts, the control of the negotiation process and the duty to register
Details
3. Governing through white-collar crime: collaboration agreements and the fight against corruption
Details
a. Collaboration agreements, the anti-corruption movement and the dynamic of “governing through crime”
Details
b. Under the law, above the law
Details
c. Investigative achievements, failures and the effectiveness discourse: collaboration religion?
Details
d. The symbiotic relationship between collaboration agreements and the Brazilian anti-corruption movement
Details
4. Conclusion: a prosperous life for consensual mechanisms in Brazilian criminal justice
Details
319–322
Conclusion
319–322
Details
323–326
Annex – List of collaboration agreements analyzed
323–326
Details
327–345
References
327–345
Details
Durchsuchen Sie das Werk
Geben Sie ein Keyword in die Suchleiste ein
CC-BY-NC-ND
Access
Leniency Policies in the Prosecution of Economic Crimes and Corruption , page 319 - 322
Conclusion
Autoren
Francisco Schertel Mendes
DOI
doi.org/10.5771/9783748922599-319
ISBN print: 978-3-8487-7849-2
ISBN online: 978-3-7489-2259-9
Chapter Preview
Chapter Preview
Share
Download PDF
Download citation
RIS
BibTeX
Copy DOI link
doi.org/10.5771/9783748922599-319
Share by email
Video schließen
Share by email Nomos eLibrary
Recipient*
Sender*
Message*
Your name
Send message
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google
Privacy Policy
and
Terms of Service
apply.
