Constitutio posterior non derogat pactis prioribus? Chiles völkerrechtliche Verträge im Kontext der Verfassungsablösung

Sven Korzilius

doi:10.17104/0044-2348-2022-3-605

Contents
- Chapter Expand | CollapseAuthorsPage
- 1–528 Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis 1–528
- 529–540 Comment 529–540
  - The Disparate State of Refugee Protection in the European Union Dana Schmalz Dana Schmalz
- 541–700 Abhandlungen 541–700
  - 541–576 „Human Rights With Chinese Characteristics“ – Ein Beitrag Chinas zur Weiterentwicklung internationaler Menschenrechte? Charlotte Magnus Charlotte Magnus 541–576
  - 577–604 Lockdown by Press Conference? COVID-19 and the Rule of Law in New Zealand and Austria Theresa Upperton, Thomas Buocz, Magdalena Nemeth, Iris Eisenberger Theresa Upperton, Thomas Buocz, Magdalena Nemeth, Iris Eisenberger 577–604
  - 605–640 Constitutio posterior non derogat pactis prioribus? Chiles völkerrechtliche Verträge im Kontext der Verfassungsablösung Sven Korzilius Sven Korzilius 605–640
  - 641–670 ‘Principled Resistance’ Meets ‘ultra vires’: NewTechniques in Opposing ECtHR Judgments Marten Breuer Marten Breuer 641–670
  - 671–700 Ein ständiger Sitz der Europäischen Union im UN-Sicherheitsrat Christian Magaard Christian Magaard 671–700
- 701–724 Rezensionsaufsatz 701–724
  - Warum verliert die deutsche Verfassungsrechtswissenschaft an internationalem Einfluss und was kann dagegen getan werden? András Jakab András Jakab
- 725–742 Buchbesprechungen 725–742
  - 725–732 Boysen, Sigrid: Die postkoloniale Konstellation, Natürliche Ressourcen und das Völkerrecht der Moderne Birgit Peters Birgit Peters 725–732
  - 733–742 Kasperidus, Stephan: Die völkerrechtliche Verantwortlichkeit im Rahmen der Pacht fremden Hoheitsgebiets. Carmen Thiele Carmen Thiele 733–742
Durchsuchen Sie das Werk
Geben Sie ein Keyword in die Suchleiste ein
CC-BY-SA Access

Zeitschrift für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht / Heidelberg Journal of International Law , page 605 - 640

Constitutio posterior non derogat pactis prioribus? Chiles völkerrechtliche Verträge im Kontext der Verfassungsablösung

Autoren

Sven Korzilius

DOI
- doi.org/10.17104/0044-2348-2022-3-605
- ISSN: 0044-2348
- ISSN online: 2942-3562
Abstract

Chile’s International Treaties in the Context of the Replacement of the Constitution From a public international law perspective, the domestic process ideally does not affect treaty obligations. Already in normal times, however, there are innumerable options to retreat from treaties. The exceptional case of constitutional replacement hardly extends these. Could the ‘eternity clause’ of 2019 (Art. 135 IV of the Chilean Constitution), which states that the contents of international treaties are to be respected, subject the Constitutional Convention to stronger ties than international treaty law itself? This article rejects readings that tried to perpetuate the substantive content of the treaties or to forbid changes that would make termination of treaties necessary. The lack of justiciability and the principle of truthfulness of norms speak against them. The clause only warned to proceed in a manner that is gentle on international law. Based on this, the third part shows Chile’s wide margin to cancel or alter existing treaty regimes and sees opportunities for respect of treaties by practical concordance and the activation of secondary legal protection in accordance with international law in the event of contradictions that cannot be resolved in accordance with treaties.
Share