Give a Court an Inch and It Will Take a Yard? The Exercise of Jurisdiction over Incidental Issues

Fabian Simon Eichberger

doi:10.17104/0044-2348-2021-1-235

Contents
- Chapter Expand | CollapseAuthorsPage
- I–IV Titelei/Inhaltsverzeichnis I–IV
- 1–6 Editorial Armin von Bogdandy, Anne Peters Armin von Bogdandy, Anne Peters 1–6
- 7–22 Comment 7–22
  - The Importance of Having Rights Anne Peters Anne Peters
- 23–46 In Focus: Relaunch of the ZaöRV/HJIL as an Open Access Journal 23–46
  - Opening Access, Closing the Knowledge Gap? Analysing GC No. 25 on the Right to Science and Its Implications for the Global Science System in the Digital Age Raffaela Kunz Raffaela Kunz
- 47–264 Abhandlungen 47–264
  - 47–88 Exploring the Autonomy of the European Union Legal Order Koen Lenaerts, José A. Gutiérrez-Fons, Stanislas Adam Koen Lenaerts, José A. Gutiérrez-Fons, Stanislas Adam 47–88
  - 89–116 The Role of International Law in Vaccinating Against COVID-19: Appraising the COVAX Initiative Armin von Bogdandy, Pedro A. Villarreal Armin von Bogdandy, Pedro A. Villarreal 89–116
  - 117–146 COVID-19 and the Scope of the UN Security Council’s Mandate to Address Non-Traditional Threats to International Peace and Security Erin Pobjie Erin Pobjie 117–146
  - 147–234 Constitutions and Contagion – European Constitutional Systems and the COVID-19 Pandemic Angelo Jr Golia, Laura Hering, Carolyn Moser, Tom Sparks Angelo Jr Golia, Laura Hering, Carolyn Moser, Tom Sparks 147–234
  - 235–264 Give a Court an Inch and It Will Take a Yard? The Exercise of Jurisdiction over Incidental Issues Fabian Simon Eichberger Fabian Simon Eichberger 235–264
- 265–292 Buchbesprechungen 265–292
  - 265–270 Craven, Matthew/Pahuja, Sundhya/Simpson, Gerry (eds.): International Law and the Cold War (2019) Ned Richardson-Little Ned Richardson-Little 265–270
  - 271–276 Casey, Christopher A.: Nationals Abroad: Globalization, Individual Rights, and the Making of Modern International Law (2020) Ntina Tzouvala Ntina Tzouvala 271–276
  - 277–280 Swatek-Evenstein, Mark: A History of Humanitarian Intervention (2020) Jacob Katz Cogan Jacob Katz Cogan 277–280
  - 281–286 Ferrari, Guiseppe Franco (ed.): Judicial Cosmopolitanism. The Use of Foreign Law in Contemporary Constitutional Systems (2019) Sebastian Graf von Kielmansegg Sebastian Graf von Kielmansegg 281–286
  - 287–292 Frankenberg, Günter: Autoritarismus. Verfassungstheoretische Perspektiven (2020) Claudio Franzius Claudio Franzius 287–292
Durchsuchen Sie das Werk
Geben Sie ein Keyword in die Suchleiste ein
CC-BY-SA Access

Zeitschrift für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht / Heidelberg Journal of International Law , page 235 - 264

Give a Court an Inch and It Will Take a Yard? The Exercise of Jurisdiction over Incidental Issues

Autoren

Fabian Simon Eichberger

DOI
- doi.org/10.17104/0044-2348-2021-1-235
- ISSN: 0044-2348
- ISSN online: 2942-3562
Abstract

This article seeks to clarify how international courts and tribunals should decide whether to exercise jurisdiction over incidental issues. It considers such issues incidental, which would fall outside the subject-matter jurisdiction of an international court or tribunal if submitted separately, but which courts rule upon to resolve disputes falling within their jurisdiction. International courts and tribunals have employed diverse approaches to decide whether to exercise jurisdiction over incidental issues. This contribution will assess their decisions to distil what criteria are best suited to ensure the effectiveness of the underlying treaty while taking into account the fundamental importance of state consent for judicial dispute settlement. It concludes that the necessity to exercise jurisdiction over the incidental issue and the nature of the issue should be the guiding criteria for international courts and tribunals, while the character of the jurisdictional basis may serve as supplementary criterion.
Share